Haa: More than 30 people from nine households of Gyensa village in Bji gewog, Haa are sharing a tent as their houses were damaged by the earthquake of September 18. The tent was given by a Royal Bhutan Army Officer yesterday. Till then, the families had taken shelter under a maruti van.
A 29-year-old tour guide, Wangchuk, said that there has been no help by the dzongkhag officials till date. “It is scary having to live in a tent with more than 30 people in the dark. Officials from the Bhutan Power Corporation Limited (BPCL) came here three times. We requested them for light but they said that the dzongkhag should provide the equipment,” he said, adding that he is feeling as if years have passed.
However, the Haa Dzongrab, Jamba Tenzin said that the dzongkhag is doing everything possible. Lack of manpower, scattered gewogs and villages and the need to assess the damages as quick as possible are hurdles that the dzongkhag faces. “We do not want to leave anyone unassisted. But people should understand that there are four gewogs with several villages which are scattered.”
He said that assessment and rescue teams were sent as soon as the earthquake struck and added that it is not wise to conduct the assessments fast. Reminding the problems that emerged in Trashiyangtse dzongkhag after the earthquake of September 21, 2009, because of improper assessments, the Dzongrab said everything should be conducted properly. “The government wants the report immediately, but most of the houses are cracked and it takes time to differentiate between the severely damaged and the minor ones. And to do this it takes time.”
When asked if the assistances could be provided first and the assessments done later, he said it would be better.
Concerning allegations that he did not visit the affected areas, Jamba Tenzin said someone has to stay in the headquarters for coordination. “Representatives from the dzongkhag are in the fields and I have to stay here to communicate with them and the Ministry in Thimphu.”
The Dzongrab clarified that tents and tarpaulins were issued right after the earthquake. “However, we could not give to everybody because we did not have enough.” He said the dzongkhag has purchased tarpaulin, which will be handed over to the people today.
Meanwhile, the nine families are still sharing the tent. “Sometimes, I feel like going into the damaged house. But, I get scared,” Wangchuk said, adding that the people are waiting for help.
In Bhutan Today 22 September 2011
It is very obvious that the country like Bhutan, ruled by absolute monarch and chant the pride of having established democracy would priorities evaluation of damages to the properties, whether state or private concerns. I remember an incident that took place in 1983 in the RICB (Royal Insurance Corporation of Bhutan). A field officer, who had been on an official tour had met with an accident. On hearing about the incident, the executives concerned showed their first concern towards the vehicle, which was damaged a little. However, the officer concerned, who used the vehicle and met with accident had received serious leg injury. He was however not given any attention for his first aid by the executives, but explanation was called and the delay thus led to hospitalization for about two weeks owing to internal bleeding and a minor leg injury.
It is saddening to find that the Dzongkhag officials could not reach to the rescue of the earth quack victims on time and the panicking officials could not but say, “someone has to stay in the headquarters for coordination”. According to the concerned dzongkhag official, “Representatives from the dzongkhag are in the fields and I have to stay here to communicate with them and the Ministry in Thimphu.” In the process of explaining their administrative set backs and weaknesses, the poor public has to suffer in absence of their timely attention. If the government failed to take care of the victims of natural calamities on time, what would they do by just debating in the parliament for their perks and other allowances.
The several drawbacks from the government’s side not only in terms of timely relief and evacuation of earth quack victims, but also other social problems that are mushrooming in the ever growing population need to be drawn government’s attention – the causes of domestic conflicts, family breaking, drug addicts, alcoholics, thefts, smuggling, vandalisation of sacrilegious monuments and robbery of such religious artifacts etc. are daily reported by the national news paper and less is reported about the government’s strategies to control these anti-social activities.
Is this a good governance?? Does the situation reflect the existence of happiness in the people??